Toyota GR Corolla Forum - Ownership Discussion banner

Best Oil and Filter Combo

32K views 107 replies 25 participants last post by  Jacques  
#1 ·
Hey guys, im currently closes to my 641 break-in oil change. I was wondering what oil and filter combo I should uses. I have been watching Project Farms and Brand Ranks to see which oil filter combo I should go for. Project Farms say the best oil is Amsoil Signature followed by Redline then Pennzoil Ultra Platunim. Brand Rank said the best filters where Purolator Boss, Amsoil, then Fram Endurance. The thing is I'm also trying to go with cost also. I know Pennzoil goes on sale alot and can be found much more easily. The same can be said for the Purolator Boss and the Fram Endurance.

It's my only car currently and I'm in college trying my best to have my car last until I get a stable career, so maybe 10 year or over 150k. So I guess I wanna ask what do you guys use?
 
#4 ·
I’ve been using Amsoil since 2011. It’s been my preferred oil for all my vehicles (past and present).

It has consistently ranked #1. Recommended by many tuners and used by many aftermarket companies. Fortune Auto is one example.

I personally won’t ever go with another brand but that’s me. But don’t take my word for it. Their history and reputation speaks for itself.
 
#20 ·
I'm a former AMSOil dealer for nearly 10 years, but I had a strong focus on the technical details - nothing on the sales side honestly.

AMSOil's oils are top notch. Pennzoil Ultra Platinum is nearly identical at a fraction of the cost.

Per filters, AMSOil and Royal Purple are identical. Fram's Ultra Synthetic are actually better than AMSOil's EA filters. I thought it was BS at first.

And then you see ISO results for the filters and see that the Fram Ultra Synthetic is no joke, and its HALF the cost of the AMSOil filter.

But, does that mean that I'll never run AMSOil filters? Nah. I'll run a bypass kit. Those bypass filters are f'n incredible! Nothing comes close to those!
 
#6 ·
There was a very detailed comparison done on some big youtube channel, where they did multiple testing on numerous oils. Overall winner was amsoil, but it barely beat out Pennzoil ultra platinum. The price difference between the 2 is not worth getting the Amsoil over the Pennzoil IMO. Im gonna stick with the pennzoil ultra Platinum. Plus its more readily available than Amsoil. With filters, im just gonna stick with the OEM one, but not the one for the GR, the slightly longer one (forgot the part number)
 
#10 ·
I am sure you’ll get different responses regarding this topic.
you’ll have someone who will say just follow the owners manual…. And use the free ones that come with your car. So 5000 miles at Toyota dealership.

On the other hand, you’ll have someone like @moving_target01, who truly believe that you should change oil every 500 miles until 3000.

Truth is probably somewhere in the middle. If you will only do it once before 5000, I’d say pay top dollar and get it done for peace of mind. That can Purolator Boss and Amsoil. If you want to do it 4 or more times, then something a little more in-line with Toyota OEM filter and Pennzoil Ultra platinum. Either choices will not be bad or wrong, just what you’re comfortable with.
 
#14 ·
Honestly it's simple. After five thousand miles of typical use (for the owner), take a sample of the oil and send it to Blackstone for analysis. That should remove any doubt from one's mind.

I sent them my own after roughly 5,000 HARD miles (weekend trip to the mountains and 200 miles flogging around VIR) and they said hey your oil is still in great shape. Both of my aforementioned activities involved sustained engine oil operation above 245°F.
 
#17 ·
I've got the 0W-20 Advanced Super Tech (20,000 mile variant) in mine right now. It meets requirements all Toyota requirements. I put it in at 1200 miles and am going in early for my 5000 mile service, so I thought I'd experiment a little. I plan to run the Super Tech around 2500 miles. I will send in a sample to Blackstone after running it, and then again after the Toyota oil has been changed back in and run a few thousand miles.

I've been watching temps and oil pressure before and after the change. If anything, it's holding a little more pressure and the temps are the same or a tad lower. Really the variations in the readings are so minimal that they could just be weather/driving parameter related.

Before I get any hate mail, I drive my car fairly easy (I'm old) (<6000rpm) with only occasional WOT. 2500 easy miles with new oil that meets Toyota standards is not gonna harm my engine. If I happen to schedule my track day before the 2500 miles, I'll be pre-track changing the oil again anyway.
 
#26 · (Edited)
I break this down into 2 categories.

1. I need this in 2 days or less.

2. I will order everything 2 weeks in advance.

For the '2 days or less' I would go with:
Fram Synthetic Endurance filter
Pennzoil Ultra Platinum oil

For the 'ordering in advance' I would go with:
Fram Synthetic Endurance filter
AMSOil Signature Series oil

It cannot be ignored that AMSOil products do cost quite a bit more. Are they absolutely the better items to go with? The filter? No. The oil, yes.

The key details are that the Fram Ultra Synthetic captures more particulates, and smaller particulates than AMSOil does.

AMSOil has a much better result in regards to the NOACK volatility test (that determines how much oil burns off at high temperature, like inside the turbo).

This thread goes into oil filter details.

This thread goes into oil details.

* Updated the oil filter recommendation * 2024.11.27
 
#44 ·
I break this down into 2 categories.

1. I need this in 2 days or less.

2. I will order everything 2 weeks in advance.

For the '2 days or less' I would go with:
Fram Ultra Synthetic filter
Pennzoil Ultra Platinum oil

For the 'ordering in advance' I would go with:
Fram Ultra Synthetic filter
AMSOil Signature Series oil

It cannot be ignored that AMSOil products do cost quite a bit more. Are they absolutely the better items to go with? The filter? No. The oil, yes.

The key details are that the Fram Ultra Synthetic captures more particulates, and smaller particulates than AMSOil does.

AMSOil has a much better result in regards to the NOACK volatility test (that determines how much oil burns off at high temperature, like inside the turbo).

This thread goes into oil filter details.

This thread goes into oil details.
One thing that caught my attention is that the oil filter from Amsoil is cheaper then Wix XP, Purolator Boss, Mobile1, and K&N. For my other vehicles the Amsoil was always the more expensive option. That doesn't seem ro be the case with the GR. It's $9.85 with membership.
 
#30 ·
Stick to what the manual says.
Hahahaha. Just like what you’ve seen…. Anything about oil/oil filter, there will be different opinions.
some will say, “Toyota knows what they’re doing….”
Some will say, “you should run a better/heavier oil….”

if you don’t planning on tinker much by yourself, and want to keep warranty intact, “I” would run the recommended spec. If you’re sure you will mod as soon as possible, and can take care of most of the problem yourself or with a good friend, then do whatever you want.
Yay your probably right. There so many different options and never really a clear answer. It's just like when I had my WRX and everyone said to use T6 5w40 instead of 5w30. Ill just stick to 0w20 just to be on the safe side.
 
#32 ·
I normally run 0w-20 with exception to track days. I swap it out for 5w-30. So unless you’re going to track your car, stick with 0w-20.

As far as filters, I run the larger Toyota F1 filter on track days and then switch back to my main filter, the Fram Ultra Synthetic. The larger size though (XG4386).

On track days I personally prioritize flow rate over filtration which is why I run the F1. Although it wouldn’t hurt to run the larger Fram. It’s a balancing act at this point and personal preference.
 
#33 ·
It also depends on the temperatures you're running at. A 0w20 may be perfectly fine for normal daily commuting with oil temps around 200°F, but at much higher temps/load its too thin, such as a track day, ergo a thicker viscosity is preferred. Running a moderately thicker viscosity all the time isn't bad, just causes more fluid friction at lower temps and reduces efficiency.
 
#43 ·
Big thing I learned about oil today is 100% synthetic vs Full synthetic. Is it true that a full synthetic doesn't even have to be full synthetic call it that? I read that to legally call a oil full synthetic it just has to be 10% synthetic and then the rest could be a mineral oil. But isn't that just a synthetic blend? I know Mobile1, Vavoline, LiqiMoly, and Pennzoil admits this. That would mean the only true 100% synthetic would be Amsoil and Motul?

This just keeps getting more confusing.
 
#51 ·
"Some define “100% synthetic” as motor oil made exclusively from Group IV polyalphaolefin (PAO) base oils. In contrast, they define “full synthetic” as an oil made from Group III base oils."


It is summarized later in that post, that it is accepted industry standards that any Group III, Group IV or Group V oil can be called either 'full synthetic' or '100% synthetic' - they are interchangeable.

The real difference is the base oil itself, and that is the true root of the question - "what are the properties of that oil?" and not so much "what does the label state/imply?"

As per a blend oil:

"Most blend oils will have a synthetic oil content varying from 10% to as much as 25%."


That is to state that a Group III oil is not a 'blend' oil, as Group III oils are accepted in the oil industry as full/100% synthetic.
 
#45 · (Edited)
Also is Amsoil Signature also worth it if I'm doing my oil changes every 2,500-5,000. For a full oil change its $66 while if I went OE its $46. Is there a big enough difference to justify the $20 dollar difference. Signature has much better protection it says compared to OE but is that only at high mileage?

I know if I wanted to do Pennzoil Ultra Platunim with Purolator Boss filter its $56. I also see alot of people using Motul V300 but that oil is $46 for only 2L also it looks like MTN Dew for some reason. I was also thinking of Kirkland motor oil for 10QT for $39. But like DaleNixon said it might blow up my engine.
 
#46 ·
Also is Amsoil Signature also worth it if I'm doing my oil changes every 2,500-5,000. For a full oil change its $66 while if I went OE its $46. Is there a big enough difference to justify the $20 dollar difference. Signature has much better protection it says compared to OE but is that only at high mileage?
For Amsoil to make all the sense, you need to run it until it breaks down, which is a long time. I had a fully tuned STI years ago. The last Amsoil lab sample I sent to Blackstone for analysis had 10k miles on the OCI. Blackstone analyzed and told me the oil was fine and to go 12k miles for the next oil change. If you are running high quality fully synthetic oil you don’t need to change it at 2500-5000 miles.